"Development of a short-form Stroke Impact Scale using a machine learning
algorithm in patients at subacute stage" 今早剛被AJOT接受刊登!!
中間還有點曲折...
審查意見卡在第1個 editor超過3個月，我一直耐心等候...之後寫信詢問，但無回音
後來國外系友提醒那位 editor出了些狀況...建議我需跟主編聯絡
聯絡主編後，主編跟我道歉也接手處理.... 只是再送第3位審查...
後面這位委員... 蠻負向的，認為這AI論文OT讀者難以消化//不合適刊登於AJOT
還好主編還喜歡這主題....
負向意見如下: My main concern about this study is its fit with AJOT. The purpose and rational are important, but the methodology and implications are very complex for an OT journal. This seems to fit better to a quantitative methodology focused paper than an OT journal.
Response: Given that ML appears to be powerful and has been successfully used in most research fields, we believe that starting to apply such methodology in OT-related research is crucial for our profession. In particular, the AJOT, as the top-rated OT journal in the world, can be a pioneer in introducing ML methods to OT readers. Regarding the concern about complex methodologies, we have added more explanations of the methodology adopted for the ML-SIS for our readers, such as how and why item contribution/importance was calculated. Moreover, the ML-related terms used in this article have been further explained to improve readability. For example, the procedure section of the manuscript has been revised.
主編最後回應: I am confident that this important research will make a valuable contribution to the literature and to the journal.
共勉之!!
感謝士捷、Inga、恭宏、沛綺、雅珍、佳燁與千瑀之協助!
Note:
1. 此文的資料由Inga（海外系友）提供，將近2年的播種（學系50週年慶聯絡上的系友）與多人努力...才有此時的成果！！
2. 提醒我聯絡主編的那位系友，是另一位50週年慶聯絡上的系友... 我的貴人真多！！
沒有留言:
張貼留言